Saul Solomon


IN SEARCH OF SAUL SOLOMON OF ST HELENA
1776 - 1852

contributed by Trevor W. Hearl



Saul SolomonIf one man dominates St.Helena's history it must, according to 'the outside world', surely be Napoleon Bonaparte. But the experience of daily life tells St.Helenians differently. Long before Napoleon arrived, Saul Solomon had founded a business that, after 200 years, still wields all-pervasive influence over their affairs. Yet the founder is as little known as St.Helena's other benefactors. So what can a search, far from Island sources, reveal about St.Helena's "Merchant-King"?

Solomon's origins seem mantled in mystery. Where and when he was born, why and how he reached St.Helena, no-one yet knows. Tradition has it that he was born in London about 1776 and in his 'teens set out for India on a ship sailing via St.Helena. There he was left at death's door and nursed back to health by an officer's family. Geoffrey Kitching, pre-war government secretary, told W.E.G.Solomon that he was a corporal in the St.Helena Corps in 1796. But the India Office Library has no record of this.

Trade rather than drill soon seduced young Solomon. Kitching thought he "first set up" in 1790; indeed Solomon & Co's notepaper declares "Established 1790". But 1990 saw no bicentenary celebration and I doubt he entered military service or trade at 14! He had "a general store and boarding house" well before 1800, however, reputedly charging 30s.[£1 .50] a day. This exorbitance brought success as St.Helena's mini-economy was most profitable when catering for 'the carriage trade'. But this needed committed workers so he sent for his brothers, Benjamin, Joseph, Lewis, and Charles who married in 1798. There also came the Moss family, whose Hannah married Joseph in 1814. Lewis married Julia Magnus in 1818, taking his other name, Gideon, as surname; Benjamin wed Eliza Chamberlain in 1823; while Saul himself was married thrice: before 1800 to Margaret (Lee?), in 1815 to Mary Chamberlain and in 1824 to Harriet Bryan.

A significant Jewish community was thus established at St.Helena. Yet it did not last. One reason was migration to the Cape from the 1820's. Joseph's family went about 1830, leading to the rise of their son, Saul (1817-92) - the famous "member for Cape Town" and founder of The Cape Argus - whose memorial is in St.James' Church, though St.Helenians do not yet claim him as a distinguished compatriot. A more potent reason, perhaps, was the integration of the remaining members into the Island community. No Jewish rites were observed; most became active Anglicans. Saul was undertaker at many Anglican funerals, in 1818 at that of Napoleon's Roman Catholic valet, Cipriani.

Anti-Semitism is nevertheless evident in remarks about "the Jew Solomon". General Lefroy relates a case of an officer in 1842 refusing to pay the "outrageous charge of old S-, a well-known Jew", which led to a Court of Inquiry on the ship home. Overcharging was the commonest complaint; even Napoleon grumbled at his 12/-[60p] lb. For macaroni, while the cost of Cipriani's funeral still makes a French author wince, "the Jew Solomon" giving Montholon the bill of 1400 gold francs "as soon as the candles were extinguished." His role as moneylender created another source of friction. Yet opinions differed, even about his shop. One sneered that it was "so run down in stock that they could not find even a paper of pins", whereas another found "everything from diamonds down to cloves and tintacks." But one official commented significantly that Solomon was "a very different man from what had been represented to [me] on [my] arrival". He did not court popularity, either as an innovator - setting up the first Island press in 1806 - or in driving a bargain. He was known at the Cape for challenging the value of deliveries when they arrived! But one Cape merchant, Richard Prince, who came in 1813 to enforce payment of Saul's debts, stayed to set up a rival concern which traded for 89 years, leaving Prince's Lodge [Bishopsholme] as his legacy.
 
 

TRADE AND INTRIGUE

Solomon's success owed much, though by no means all, to Napoleon's exile. By 1816 the population had doubled to c.8,000, bringing wealth and opportunities of a kind he was well placed to exploit. But Lieut. Basil Jackson was not impressed:
 

Solomon was not in business to entertain subalterns when there was a luxury trade and busy commercial markets to be met. For the latter he provided legal and insurance services, for the former fashions and jewellery. And whether they traded under the name of Solomon, Gideon or Moss, Saul was architect of their fortunes.

A business bonanza was not his only Napoleonic legacy, however. It earned him a reputation for dubious loyalty to the government. Hudson Lowe listed the Solomon brothers, with their clerk Bruce, as the chief suspects aiding Napoleon, finding even their name to imply "some predisposition to engage in illicit speculation." His premises, being venues for visitors and favoured entrepot for the entourages of both Governor and ex-emperor - and their ladies - became notorious for gossip and intrigue. The now wealthy merchant took an impish delight in snubbing the Governor, once refusing to lend him a silver salver wanted to impress an illustrious guest - whom he was entertaining later! He was even said to have smuggled a silken ladder into Longwood in a chest of tea to help Napoleon clamber down a cliff into a waiting boat! He was an assumed admirer of the exile and certainly Longwood's clandestine correspondence passed through his hands - at a price. In 1840, as French Consul, he was among the favoured few to accompany Napoleon's coffin aboard the Belle Poule.
 
 

A BOOM TIME FOR SOME

The Solomon empire continued to flourish for several reason, not least its owners' business acumen. To lubricate local trade and show a profit, Saul issued a token copper currency of 70,560 halfpennies "Payable at St.Helena by Solomon, Dickson and Taylor" - presumably London partners - which circulated alongside the East India Company's local coinage until the Crown took over the Island in 1836. The family's businesses were then listed as:
 

Jamestown boasted two other jewellers (Charles Oswald and Thomas Richards), a watchmaker (W.Tracy) and a silversmith (Joseph Saunders). They were trading when the Island was, wrote George Brooks Bennett, in "the full flood of its prosperity".
  During Saul's business career ships increased from about 150 to over a thousand a year, St.Helena became a haven for American whalers and a base for the Royal Navy's anti-slavery squadron, with a Vice-Admiralty Court condemning slavers and unseaworthy vessels to the benefit of Jamestown's ship chandlers.

Solomon had funds for speculation when it mattered, which perhaps explains partners such as the shadowy Dickson and Taylor, George Janisch of Teutonic Hall, and Robert Morrison, who had the fact inscribed on his grave in 1865. (Daniel Hamilton's memorial in 1867 also records service to the Company). But when calamity fell, like the collapse of the St.Helena Whale Fishery Co., it was rivals, Thomas Baker, John Scott and others, who lost, not Solomon, Gideon or Moss. Ironically, forty years later his successors ignored, or were ignorant of, this experience and made a disastrous investment in the Island whaler, Elizabeth. If Saul speculated unwisely, it has yet to be discovered. At the watershed of St.Helena history - the Island's transfer from the Company to the Crown in 1836 - he was again among the winners, as old Company landed families sold out at great loss, while merchants took their pickings and prospered.

Saul was no less skilful in climbing the social ladder as the Napoleonic era receded. Despite being 'in trade', which normally put one beyond the pale of polite society, he and his partners were invited to sit with 'gentlemen' on various committees - Benefit, Benevolent, Fire and those of other social welfare societies. Solomon, Gideon and Moss virtually ran the Annuity Fund Committee. Indicators abound of rising social status. In 1823 Saul's daughter Phoebe married Capt. T.M.Hunter of the St.Helena Artillery; in 1838 his son Henry (1806-47) became Colonial Surgeon and Health Officer, whose widow married Governor Sir Patrick Ross; they were leading Freemasons, churchwardens and JPs. For 50 years they almost monopolised the prestigious post of Sheriff ("no salary") through Saul Solomon (1839-42, 1846-50), Lewis Gideon (1842-4, 1852-6), Nathaniel Solomon (1850-52, 1859-60), George Moss (1870-80) and Saul Solomon, jun. (1880-88). In short, during the founder's lifetime, Solomon & Co. became pillars of the Establishment and of the Church, to be symbolised finally by Homfray Welby Solomon (1877-1960), grandson of Bishop Welby, Churchwarden and Member of Council (from 1898), commercial and social Island Supremo - "King Sol". His death on 30 October 1960 at 83 ended the Solomon dynasty at St.Helena, and in 1974 the firm, dominating Island production and commerce, was 'nationalised' by the St.Helena Government. Among his Victorian competitors only W.A.Thorpe & Sons now survive as independent merchant-landowners.
 
 

A VOYAGE TO REMEMBER

But to return to Saul Solomon, the founder. In 1850 he visited England with an unmarried daughter, probably for medical reasons, staying at his son-in-law's fine house, 'Eastwood' in Portishead, overlooking the Bristol Channel. There, on 6th December 1852, he died from "softening of the brain, paralysis, apoplexy, 9 months certified", accompanied only by an illiterate nurse, Mary Devine. His death certificate gave his age as 75 and occupation "Consul", reflecting his appointments as "Consul for Lübeck, Bremen, Hamburg, the Brazils, Spain and Austria; Vice-Consul for Belgium; Consular Agent for France; and Commercial Agent for Holland."

His wish to return to St.Helena was honoured in a rather bizarre sequel, revealed by Mrs.Harriet Tytler sailing home from India in 1853 on the S.V. Camperdown:
 

If the Camperdown's crew were unaware of the contents of Miss Solomon's luggage, people at St.Helena were not. Both local papers, recording the death of "our late Sheriff in London"[sic], had announced that he was to be buried on the Island, the St.Helena Chronicle reporting on 19 February "that his remains are at the Cape".
  The St.Helena Herald welcomed the news "that he is to be buried on the Island".
  Both editors expected Solomon to be remembered more as a philanthropist than as a businessman, which reads curiously today given his firm's omnipresence and local amnesia about philanthropists! While he enjoyed "the ample rewards of commercial perseverance and successful speculation", remarked the Chronicle "his heart and hand were ever open to the claims of distress and poverty."
  The Herald was more succinct:
  "The remains of Mr.Saul Solomon" arrived on 2nd March 1853 - on the Perseverance, not the Camperdown according to the Herald - and were interred two days later in the lower burial ground. The Chronicle carried a brief account next morning:
  The Herald, pursuing the philanthropic theme, mused that "even a two years' absence prior to his decease could not cool [peoples'] remembrance of his kindness to them."
  A 21 minute-gun salute was cancelled "in consequence of the severe illness of a gentleman in town", a symbolic recognition both of his importance and his humanity.
 
 

"UNDER THE TREES"

The inevitable sequel, the Executors' Sale, was held at Jamestown's traditional auction site, "under the Trees", on 23 January 1854. It was, the Herald commented, "no small land sale for such a small place as St.Helena." Indeed, it needs an economic historian to interpret its significance in the context of the Island's economy as the Executors divested themselves of prestige properties "offering a splendid opportunity for the profitable investment of capital". First to be offered among the "rare selection of most desirable dwelling-houses" were The Briars, The Brewery, and The Pavilion, "carefully preserved by the late Proprietor in the same state and with the same internal arrangement as used by the Emperor." The auctioneer, Isaac Moss, commended The Briars House, "with Coach Houses, Outbuildings and every convenience", as "one of the best and most commodious Residences in the Island" which,
 

The grounds, "before [being] planted by the East India Company with Mulberry Trees" had been, he stressed, "one of the most profitable fruit gardens in the Island."

There followed another eight "valuable properties", no fewer than six in Main Street. Lacking names and numbers, they cannot easily be identified, though to Moss and potential purchasers they were "too well known to need many particulars". The house formerly rented by Captain Knipe, "well known as the best and most convenient in Town", was apparently to be sold with vacant possession, while tenants of the others doubtless viewed proceedings with some apprehension. Three of the most desirable, "of precisely the same character", were occupied by H.Weston, Lee Solomon and Dr. Marshall, "for many years past let to highly respectable Tenants". James Scott's house and shop "in an excellent business situation was followed by the Jeweller's Shop and Dwelling House of "W.Green, near the Market". This left two "spacious premises", one on the road to Ladder Hill occupied by Mr. Beattie, "well adapted for any purpose requiring extensive space", the other "the Blacksmiths' Forge and Yard [behind] Solomon and Moss' Stores", let to J.Truebody. Finally were offered shares in the St.Helena Hotel, "a safe and profitable investment".

"There has rarely been such a large sale, or one which excited such interest" declared the Herald. "A considerable number of buyers" were joined by others "interested in watching the value of property on the Island at the present time." Some good prices were realised, but others, in the paper's opinion, were "only middling".
 

The sale raised "somewhere between £4,500 and £5,000."

Today the name Solomon is the best known in St.Helena. But only as a business. Saul Solomon is unknown, though his gravestone survives. I found it in 1971 by the north wall of St.James' Church, among those rescued when the Burial Ground was cleared to make a Children's Playground. It could hardly have been more modest:

Sacred to the Memory of S.Solomon, Esq.
who died in England
on the Sixth of December 1852
Aged 76 years



May this brief biographical reconnaissance encourage others to seek out more about the life and achievements of St.Helena's remarkable "Merchant-King".


SOURCES

ARKIN, Marcus: The Cape-St.Helena Trade 1794-1836 (Cape Town 1960)

AUBRY, O: St.Helena (Philadelphia 1936)

CHAPLIN, A: A St.Helena Who's Who (1919)

GEORGE, B.(ed.): Register of Memorials on St.Helena 1686-1973 (Jamestown 1973)

GOSSE, P: St Helena 1502-1938 (1990)

GREEN, L.G: There's a Secret Hid Away (Cape Town 1956)

HEARL, T.W.(ed.): "My Dear Daughter..."Selections from the St.Helena Reminiscences of George Brooks Bennett 1816-51 (1989)

HEARL, T. W: St.Helena '5 Social Revolution 1834-69 : The Evidence of the Brooke-Scott Letters (1991)

HEARL, T.W.: Exploring the Southern Whale Fishery at St.Helena (1991)

JACKSON, Lt. Col. B: Notes & Reminiscences or a Staff Officer (1903)

KEMBLE, J.(ed.): St.Helena during Napoleon's Exile - Gorreguer's Diary (1969)

KOHN, J. [KRAEMER, J. E. (trans.)]: 'Saul Solomon (1776-1852)'. St. Helena & Dependencies Philatelic Society Newsletter 1, 1 & 2 (Jan/Apr 1978)

LEFROY, Lady (ed.): Autobiography of General Sir John Henry Lefroy (1895)

MARTINEAU, G: Napoleon's St.Helena (New York 1969)

O'MEARA, B.E: Napoleon at St.Helena (1888)

SOLOMON, W.E. C: Saul Solomon 'The Member for Cape Town' (Cape Town 1948)

St.Helena Calendar & Directory (1825-43)

St.Helena Almanac (1856 & 1913)

St.Helena Chronicle & St.Helena Herald (17 Feb 1853 - 26 Jan 1854)

St.Helena Government: Statistical Year Book 1990. Shipping 1752-1990.

TYTLER, Harriet: An Englishwoman in India - the Memoirs of 1828-58 (1988)

VICE,D: The Coinage of British West Africa & St.Helena 1684-1958 (1983)

WATSON, G.L. de St.M: A Polish Exile with Napoleon [Piontkowski] (1912)
 


ACKNOWLEDGMENTS

For their generous assistance I am particularly indebted to Mr. Robin Gill for providing a copy of Saul Solomon's Death Certificate, to Mrs. S.Tebbutt of the Gordano Society, Portishead, for photographs of 'Eastwood' today, and to Mr. Ian Baxter of India Office Library for seeking Solomon's EIC records.
 
 

June 1994

 The St Helena Institute